- December 2022 (1)
- March 2022 (1)
- January 2022 (1)
- November 2021 (1)
- October 2021 (1)
- September 2021 (2)
- August 2021 (4)
- July 2021 (3)
- June 2021 (4)
- May 2021 (5)
- April 2021 (2)
- March 2021 (5)
Turkey's economy is like a sailing ship, going wherever the winds blow it
When it comes to the Turkish economy, it has always been best to take the long view. Have a look at the economic transformation of the country right after the customs union arrangement with the European Union. The country has transformed from a sleepy agrarian country to a mid-tech industrial one. This was a remarkable achievement, and it is the great shift that defined my generation.
How was 2021? It depends on how you look at it. Let's begin on the bright side. Take a look at Turkey’s export performance from June 2019 to June 2021 and you’ll see an increase of around 20 percent. China had an increase of more than 30 percent during the same time. We can therefore say that Turkey’s performance of meeting the post-Covid-19 global rise in import demand was on an East Asian level.
This illustrates the dynamism of the Turkish business community against all odds. Troubled bank balance sheets, indebted companies, high exchange rate volatility and rising policy uncertainty did not prevent companies from performing in 2021. The growth rate this year could be around 10 percent despite poor employment performance and rising poverty.
But why is there policy uncertainty and high exchange-rate volatility? President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has very recently become the sole economic policymaker. His highly unconventional “interest is the cause, inflation is the result” principle has made its way into policy since his son-in-law became minister of treasury and finance in 2018, and is increasingly becoming a bigger part of it.
His recent insistence on this false premise has led to predictably dire results. Erdogan fully committed to the idea in November and December, leading the Central Bank to lower its policy rate to 14 percent eventually, while inflation expectations were estimated to be rising to 30 to 35 percent early next year. The lira depreciated phenomenally.
With the interest rate on Turkish lira bank deposit rates declining to double-digit negative levels recently, the share of foreign exchange (FX) deposits in domestic banks has increased by 67 percent. That is higher than during Turkey’s 2001 banking and currency crisis.
Then came the policy reversal this last week. Turkey now has both retail FX deposits and FX-indexed Turkish lira deposits. The Turkish Treasury and the Central Bank of Turkey are footing the bill up to a certain interest rate for three-, six-, nine- and 12-month deposits.
The Central Bank will be responsible for those who are converting their FX accounts to FX-indexed lira accounts and the Treasury for those who are placing the normal Turkish lira deposit accounts to FX-indexed Turkish lira accounts. Yet the bank deposit account is not paying an interest rate per se.
If the Turkish lira depreciates more than the fixed 14 to 17 percent deposit interest rate, your return will be adjusted to the rate of lira depreciation.
Why the policy reversal? The interest rate on bank deposits has increased the narrowing wedge between the interest rate and the inflation rate considerably. Is this enough to convince Turks to turn to the Turkish lira to protect their purchasing power? We’ll soon know. It all depends on the December inflation rate to be announced on 3 January and the Monetary Policy Committee meeting on 20 January.
If the government can convince Turks that inflation is not on the rise, and if the Central Bank ceases to follow Erdogan's highly unconventional policy premises regarding the relationship between interest rates and inflation, there is a slim opening for things to improve.
The problem with Turkey these days is that policy is all about short-term tactics with no coherent strategy in mind.
“If a man knows not to which port he sails, no wind is favourable,” goes the old proverb. The erosion of our policy-making capacity in the last three years has meant that we sail here and there, wherever the winds take us, without a destination in mind.
The dynamism of the Turkish business community and their perseverance has still allowed Turkish industry to make a great comeback after the lockdowns. Yet the unevenness of post-pandemic recovery has also dragged millions into debilitating poverty.
It did not have to be a choice between one and the other. The country could have grown more evenly; it could have been a good year for big business and ordinary citizens as well. Perhaps it can once again in the future.
We simply need a coherent strategy, a sense of where we are going.